The Collage Self-Portrait Project: Beyond First Impressions - A reflexive and autoethnographic approach to knowing ourselves, knowing others, and mapping strengths, opportunities and success
Karla Perez Portilla, Senior Lecturer, Glasgow Caledonian University
Keywords: Autoethnography, positionality, reflexivity, opportunity, legal neutrality

I have been researching, teaching, and practising in Anti-discrimination Law (ADL) since around 2000. Along the way, there have always been ideas, projects, and ambitions I never got around to pursuing. At times, this felt frustrating. Recently, however, I realised that those apparently abandoned ideas have almost always become building blocks of projects I do complete. The workshop described below is one such example. Originally delivered to third-year LLB students in the Advanced Legal Studies and Skills core module and fourth-year Honours students in the Social Justice module, it is readily adaptable to a range of other groups.
The workshop has evolved over many years and is rooted in several overlapping motivations: a desire to bring authenticity, creativity and art into the classroom, making learning more meaningful and enjoyable for everyone involved (including myself), and a pressing need I identified in my role as an ADL consultant to find ways to ‘foster good relations’ and develop a more effective alternative to the infamous ‘unconscious bias training’. These issues matter deeply to me as a mother, teacher, and person whose life has been shaped by migration in migrant-hostile environments. They also reflect my commitment to taking the Equality Act 2010 seriously.
In what follows, I begin to unpack the project’s framework, exploring what the self-portraits are about, how positionality, reflexivity and autoethnography are embedded within them, the purposes these collages serve, and how they challenge the neutrality of law and contribute to legal education.
Collage self-portraits
I love arts and crafts, and I believe that if you are passionate about something, it should have a place in your teaching. Not because others must learn to love it too, but because passion is contagious, and modelling enthusiasm for what you do is itself a valuable lesson.
I am Mexican, and perhaps that also explains my attraction to self-portraiture; I grew up surrounded by the powerful and emotive images of Frida Kahlo. Collage is the chosen medium because it relies on relatively accessible technical skills, enabling broad participation, including among those who may feel less comfortable with creative approaches.
I have also found collage to be a particularly effective medium for using symbolism and metaphor to explore complex concepts and encourage reflection. That said, the workshop offers alternative forms of self-expression, including writing and spoken narratives, which participants use to complement their collage or to create alternative self-portraits.
The workshop
The workshop includes a series of activities and prompts that help participants identify words, phrases, and images that symbolise their positionality (who they are) and reflect how their identity shapes the way they understand the law and their opportunities within the legal profession.
To add another layer to their self-portrait, participants are invited to reflect on an achievement they feel proud of and to consider what made it possible. This represents a shift from the deficit model in ADL, with its tendency to focus on disadvantage and treating it as a given. In this project, I focus instead on success and on identifying the enablers that can be replicated to expand access to opportunities.
While teaching Human Rights Master's students about structural discrimination and intersectionality in the jurisprudence of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights, I realised that success, like disadvantage, can be deconstructed to reveal the conditions that produce it. Doing so helps us identify barriers to remove and enablers to replicate.
I therefore invite students to reflect on one of their own success stories, and I share my own throughout the workshop. I do so not only because stories bring abstract concepts and theories to life, but also because honesty and openness can create genuine connection and empathy among peers, and between students and teacher. I offer my experiences, with all their flaws, setbacks and successes. I believe this makes me more transparent, grounded and accountable, both as a facilitator of learning and as a learner myself.

The achievement I have shared when making my collage self-portrait is that of my work as an ADL consultant, a significant milestone I reached after years of underemployment and unpaid work while I was rebuilding professional networks following motherhood. I explored this experience in an article for Scottish Affairs, deconstructing the factors that enabled success, including reflections on my migratory status and shifting positions of privilege and disadvantage.
My achievement has been supported by access to education, scholarship funding from primary school to PhD level, and having a mother who prioritised my learning English. Being mestiza rather than Indigenous in Mexico also afforded structural advantages rooted in racial inequality. I further benefited from not needing paid employment while studying, which allowed me to focus on my education and gain research experience early. I had my husband's support in raising our son, which allowed me to publish a revised version of my PhD thesis as a monograph, which in turn opened a range of professional opportunities.
These are examples of privileges that enabled my professional achievements. Thus, in this sense, privilege may be a missing link in identifying and addressing disadvantage and discrimination. It helps reveal both barriers and enablers to opportunity. Enablers such as financial security, education, and traineeships can be extended to others, while barriers such as patriarchal norms and restrictions, nepotism, favouritism and racism should be unveiled and dismantled.
Reflecting on privilege can therefore move us beyond the deficit model of anti-discrimination work and towards a focus on the conditions that make success possible. Workshop participants are invited to use autoethnography in this way, reflecting on their own achievements and the factors that enabled them.
How can this workshop challenge the neutrality of law and support legal education?
The collage self-portraits project begins from the premise that law is not neutral. Legal rules, institutions, and policies are often presented as objective and universal, yet they frequently overlook how identity, power, privilege, and disadvantage shape people's experiences of respect, exclusion, and access to opportunities and services. Through the creation of self-portraits, participants move beyond first impressions, presenting a fuller picture of themselves through images, symbols, and narratives that communicate dimensions of identity and experience that might otherwise remain invisible. In doing so, they challenge assumptions and stereotypes while creating opportunities for mutual learning, recognition of shared experiences, and a deeper appreciation of the complexity of others' lives.
At its core, the self-portrait collage workshop invites participants to explore identity in its fullest sense. Rather than reducing people to a single characteristic or experience, it encourages consideration of the multiple dimensions of identity that shape opportunity, success, and exclusion. Engaging with the complexity of our own stories and those of others deepens understanding of intersectionality and of how privilege, discrimination, advantage, and disadvantage operate in practice.

The methodology is equally significant. Through a hands-on creative activity, participants bring something uniquely human to the process. The work requires reflection, judgement, emotion, interpretation, and artistic expression through the symbolism and metaphors represented in the collage materials. Creating together enables participants to exchange perspectives, learn from one another, and build supportive relationships. The experience fosters memorable forms of learning that can endure long after the workshop has ended.
I have used metaphor and collage in my teaching before because they create vivid mental images and invite ongoing reflection.
Practising existential solidarity in the age of AI
The workshop can be seen as an exercise in existential solidarity, understood by Selinger as the comfort of hearing from other people who can speak to struggles we identify with and care about. By sharing stories and experiences, participants recognise both their individuality and their interconnectedness. The project creates space for people to find their voice, gain confidence in their perspective, and value lived experience as a source of knowledge. The result is an output that is original, contextualised, situated, and accountable.
At a time when many people inhabit polarised spaces and echo chambers, this approach offers an opportunity to cultivate nuance, complexity, and empathy. By engaging carefully with our own experiences and those of others, we can develop a richer understanding of the social world and resist simplistic narratives about identity and difference.
Ultimately, this project is about storytelling with purpose. Its value extends beyond the classroom, generating insights that can help others improve their practice across the public, private, and third sectors. By sharing stories that reveal both barriers and possibilities, participants contribute to knowledge that can inform fairer practices, more inclusive policies, and more responsive legal frameworks. In this sense, the project is not only about understanding the world as it is, but also about imagining how it could become more just.





Comments